Monday, January 8, 2007

* Troutman Caught 'Hook Line & Sinker'

There will be plenty of coverage on 20th ward Alderman Troutman's arrest by the FBI on 'pay to play' bribery charges from other media outlets - this is all you're getting from the 'Broken Heart'.

But before you go thinking she's the only one doing this, let's take a look back and read what I call....

* The Best Letter to the Editor Ever Written

Sun-Times
Letters to the Editor

Thank you for finally illuminating a problem that community activists, residents, and preservationists have known about for decades, that zoning is for sale in the city of Chicago.

Ostensibly enacted to protect the health, safety, and welfare of the general public, the City of Chicago has made a mockery of that ideal by turning the Zoning Ordinance into nothing more than a full employment plan for real estate developers and zoning attorneys, not to mention the most effective fund-raising tool for politicians.

While the abuses of the Hired Truck Scandal can be easily corrected by firing dozing workers and recouping the cost of a little wayward asphalt that has gone missing in the middle of the night, the messes made by bad development will linger throughout our neighborhoods for generations.

For far too long, our neighborhoods have been prostituted for the profit and gain of a few, to the detriment of many. Unfortunately, many of our city's aldermen and the Zoning Board of Appeals have been all too willing to help facilitate that process by acting as the . . . Well, perhaps we need not complete that metaphor.

They say that when the cat's away, the mice will play. Unfortunately, the cat is dead and the mice have taken complete control of the house.

The fact that the professional recommendations of the Department of Planning and Development and the Department of Zoning are often brushed aside is a matter of routine for those of us who have to bear witness to this corrupted process. Community residents are at the mercy of a system that is so completely slanted in favor of developers that it borders on criminal.

Zoning meetings are always during business hours and last for hours, making attendance by the general public difficult. The public notification process is a joke, and is seldom properly enforced anyway. Ironically, the onus is now on the community to figure out when these zoning hearings occur since the notification process was quietly amended last November, eliminating the requirement that developers notify property owners within 250 feet when a zoning hearing is scheduled to take place. Furthermore, the signs required to be posted on the property announcing a zoning change often disappear, or are never posted to begin with.

If a community resident somehow does manage to make it down to City Hall for a hearing, agenda items are regularly taken out of order, or taken off the agenda all together. A favored trick of the aldermen is to defer potentially contentious zoning issues without notifying community stakeholders beforehand, many of whom have arranged to take time off from work in order to testify. Of course, the zoning attorney and developer are always warned well in advance that their case has been deferred, so as to not waste their precious time. Those hearings are then quietly rescheduled.

Unfortunately, these techniques are a time-honored tradition in Chicago and ensure minimum public participation from the very people who will be affected most by these dubious overdevelopment proposals.

The Sun-Times has discovered the tip of the iceberg regarding the issue of exploitative zoning in Chicago. We encourage your paper to continue to delve deeper into this story, much like you did with the Hired Truck Scandal.

Jonathan Fine, president;
Michael Moran, vice president,
Preservation Chicago

21 comments:

Craig Gernhardt said...

I was looking over the charges by the FBI and I came upon this affordable housing tidbit. Are you looking to buy a $300,000 condo and take out a mortgage? Check this out.

During the processing of the loan application, Harris employees noticed significant problems with TROUTMAN’s application, including the fact that TROUTMAN’s debt to income ratio was not acceptable, in Harris’ view, in order to satisfy Harris that TROUTMAN would be able to make her monthly mortgage payment for a $300,000 loan.

A Harris employee contacted CW2 and informed CW2 that TROUTMAN’s debt to income ratio was “tight” and asked if TROUTMAN could show any additional sources of income, other than her City of Chicago aldermanic salary.


Comment Blognotes: So when you're looking for that perfect condo around $300,000 - in order to be able to afford it you need to earn over $100,000 a year. It doesn't even matter that you're a Alderman. That's according to Harris bank.

Levois said...

That was a great letter. And she definitely had her hand in the proverbial cookie jar.

Isaac Marshall said...

she definitely should do some time, but i think that letter generalizes a bit much.

in wards like troutman, who cares what the zoning is! there are so many vacant lots and underdevelopment, the city should make concessions to help anyone who has a plan to develop in these areas.

Hugh said...

> this is all you're getting from the 'Broken Heart'.

Whoa, bro - look, I'm disappointed as you are as to where the Fed's started working on Aldermen, but you might regret write this off too quickly as a 20th story.

Check out the Feds' press release:

CHICAGO ALD. ARENDA TROUTMAN ARRESTED ON FEDERAL BRIBERY CHARGES

It's a fascinating read, a behind-the scenes look behind close doors at a Chicago Alderman's office. Lots of juicy details not in the papers yet.

One aspect that stood out for me was that in addition to cash money and campaign contributions Troutman played hardball with the developer for a commercial condo she would OWN. Kinda put me in a mind of the deal Moore brokered with Coe for DevCorp at Morse & Greenview.

Hugh said...

In another episode, a member of the Alderman's staff borrows a couple of police officers for muscle while he shakes down a developer for rehabbing a building without permits. The staffer wasn't upset there were no permits, he was upset the developer hadn't "taken care of the office." The developer slipped some cash to the staffer in the alley behind the Alderman's office and finished his rehab.

Had a real ring of truth for me.

Craig Gernhardt said...

Stop Hugh, don't ruin the plot. I'm only on page 10. I had a CAPS meeting to go to.

Hugh said...

SPOILERS ALERT

You guys gotta read this. It's great stuff!

Indictment: US v. Troutman

TROUTMAN added,

“Well, the thing is, most aldermen, most politicians are hos.”

Hugh said...

Our Aldermen have NEEDS! This is the kind of thing that can happen when we are not sensitive enough.

IT'S HARD OUT THERE

“Shit, I’ll take it, I need some money...”

“Everyone needs me, shit, what about me, I need something too.”

Hugh said...

Later in the meeting, TROUTMAN told CW2 [co-operating witness two] that CW2 could urge the investor to buy the fundraising tickets because she was,

“...saving him money on zoning. Saving money on all this shit. I talked to the zoning commissioner her fucking self and the planning commissioner...”

Hugh said...

potty mouth!

Toni said...

The zoning and/or building commission should require proof not move on phone calls. Gee, I wonder how many illegal rehabs and construction sites have fallen off the inspectors watch list while the developer owns the property and is 'donating'?

CoconspiratorA and CW1.....

Then what happens? Go after the victims who purchase the unzoned, no permit properties? Sounds terribly familiar to me.

Can we dig up the yeas and nays on that end of 2006 vote?

Hugh said...

A lot of sleepless nights in the bedrooms of our Aldermen tonight, as they toss & turn, staring at the ceiling, going over & over all the meetings they've had with developers lately...

... how do I know he was for real?

... was he wearing a wire?

Hugh said...

> CoconspiratorA

... a current City employee

... a Troutman staff person

... an officer in Troutman's campaign committee

Stay tuned, folks - there's LOTS of family on Troutman's staff and committees!

Craig Gernhardt said...

Hugh said....>"A lot of sleepless nights in the bedrooms of our Aldermen tonight"

Now they'll know what I went through last night!

Hugh said...

Did you guys catch that Troutman's developer pal had a cocaine biz sideline?

Or vice versa he was laundering crack dollars into real estate development.

He paid Troutman off with thousands in twenties.

An aldermanic re-election committee funded with drug money.

Craig Gernhardt said...

Aldermanic needs:

The mole, we'll call him CW2 is a alleged mortgage fraud expert.

TROUTMAN told CW2 that she was currently paying $2,200 per month in mortgage payments and asked CW2 to help her again refinance her mortgage in order to lower her monthly payment. TROUTMAN added, “Well what I need when you come back, I really need to invest, I need to, my credit is good, I got good, I need to get some income property...and I need it, I need to have some money, I need another income.” CW2 asked if she wanted a steady income, and TROUTMAN responded that she did.

Hugh said...

" ... before Monday I'm not sure I would have put Troutman on my Top Ten List of Aldermen Most Worthy of Indictment ... "

Chicago's wards still land of opportunity for corruption
Mark Brown, Sun-Times

Hugh said...

Note to US Attorney's Office, Northern Illinois

William J P Banks, 36th
Chairman, Committee on Zoning

As of 10/8/2006

Friends of William J P Banks $485,723.59
Citizens to Elect Committeeman William J P Banks $363,810.96

Total $849,534.55

YIKES!

Banks has amassed MORE THAN 8 YEARS of the salary of the office he is seeking in the campaign war chest for that office.

Craig Gernhardt said...

Arenda Troutman's sister lodged challenges to several of the alderman's opponents in the municipal election, but she did so using a different last name, causing those being challenged to cry foul.

Hugh said...

Troutman Prayer Vigil

Jocelyn said...

annie- I suggest you read that affidavit and see what you think after that. It's pretty damning.

'Broken Heart' Past Blogs